How to kill a person with impunity. Mockery of justice

[Адвокат]

How to kill a person with impunity
02/20/2010
The investigation of the most sensational Irkutsk accident last year ends very predictably.
His culprit, Anna Shavenkova, who shot down two girls at full speed in the very center of Irkutsk, suddenly turned out to be not the culprit of the incident, but his witness.
Recall that on December 2, 2009, Anna Shavenkova at high speed flew onto the sidewalk near the BUGEP admissions office on Lenin Street, and literally smeared two women on the porch: 34-year-old Elena and 27-year-old Julia Pyatkov. The details of the accident were recorded by the outdoor surveillance camera BSUEP. The video widely distributed on the Internet shows how Anna Shavenkova, leaving the car, did not pay any attention to the victims and began to carefully examine the damage to her car.
As a result of the accident, Elena Pyatkova died in the hospital. Her sister Yulia Pyatkova suffered severe injuries of the musculoskeletal system and remained disabled for life.
As a rule, the picture is clear in such accidents. The traffic police for the investigation of the incident lasts a week, the court for sentencing - one half-hour meeting. However ... it was not someone who was driving, but the daughter of the chairman of the regional election commission. And spun around ...
Almost three months have passed. During this time, a competent lawyer found the key to the heart of a passionless Themis. And - lo and behold - the culprit of the incident, who killed one person and forever mutilated the second, was not at all the culprit, but only a witness.
The court has not yet established who is responsible for the accident. It is likely that the car will be the culprit. And Anna Shavenkova just by chance, was in the driver's seat. Purely as a witness. And, as a witness, she is not only not to blame, but also likely to receive compensation for moral damage and nervous stress.
Interestingly, the investigation was not even puzzled by such a banal procedure as a driver’s blood test for traces of alcohol. Although this procedure is mandatory. Instead, the affected women were carefully examined for alcohol. Probably, the investigation hoped that they were so drunk that they themselves rushed under the wheels of a traveling car ...
The cynicism of this story did not leave anyone indifferent in Irkutsk. In addition to Anna Shavenkova herself. She never even called the hospital to Julia ...
Anna Shavenkova will not be punished. She will not even be taken away her rights. Tomorrow she will drive again. Be careful.
Help:
Shavenkova Anna Alexandrovna , 28 years old, consultant for the apparatus of the faction of the runway "United Russia" of the Legislative Assembly of the Irkutsk Region.
Shavenkova Lyudmila Ivanovna , Chairman of the Election Commission of the Irkutsk Region.
Born in 1954. Education - higher (legal). Appointed to the Commission by the Governor of the Irkutsk Region on the proposal of the Central Election Commission of the Russian Federation. Work experience in the electoral system: from 1995 - member of the commission with a casting vote, from 1995 to 2007 - secretary of the Election Commission of the Irkutsk region, from 2007 to 2008 - deputy chairman of the Election Commission of the Irkutsk region, in 2008 - deputy chairman of the interim election commission for the election of deputies of the Legislative Assembly of the Irkutsk region of the first convocation.
Source: Information Center "BABR.RU"

 

[Адвокат]

08/17/2010 Kirov District Court of Irkutsk sentenced against Anna Shavenkova, who received wide publicity in the case, thanks to the video from the scene of the accident posted on the Internet. The public was shocked and indignant that the woman, having hit two pedestrians, did not even look in their direction, not to mention the fact that she did not try to help them. Instead, Anna Shavenkova began to inspect her car and make a cell phone call.
The court found Anna Shavenkova guilty of an offense under Part 3 of Art. 264 of the Criminal Code (violation of the rules of the road and the operation of a vehicle, which, through negligence, resulted in the death of a person and causing serious harm to human health), and sentenced him to 3 years in prison with serving his sentence in a penal colony. In accordance with Part 1 of Art. 82 of the Criminal Code the execution of sentences is delayed by 14 years (!) until the child reaches Shavenkova 14 years of age, ie Until March 6, 2024, Shavenkova was deprived of the right to drive a car for a period of 3 years.
The injured party is not satisfied with the verdict and intends to appeal it.

 

[Anonymous]

Formally, a court decision is legal, but does it comply with the principles:
Justice - in terrible agony, one person died, another became disabled ... and for this - 3 years in prison, to a person who did not even compensate for the damage caused?
the inevitability of punishment - everyone understands that in 14 years Anna Shavenkova will be released from serving her sentence in connection with exemplary behavior
equality of parties - it is difficult to believe that the circumstance that the convict is the daughter of the chairman of the regional election commission Lyudmila Shavenkova did not play a role

 

[Адвокат]

Der Prozess gegen Anna Shavenkova fand nicht so sehr Resonanz aufgrund der Identität der Angeklagten, sondern aufgrund des Zynismus ihres Verhaltens unmittelbar nach dem Unfall, aufgrund dessen der erste eindeutig unfaire Prozess gegen eine 14-jährige Bewährungsstrafe abgesagt wurde.
Der Prozess im Fall von Anna Shavenkova ist nicht abgeschlossen. Laut der Anwältin A. Shavenka verursachte ein Kopfstoß am Airbag während eines Unfalls, einer Schwangerschaft und eines Schocks nach dem Unfall ihr unangemessenes Verhalten. Eine forensische psychiatrische Untersuchung ist für Ende Januar 2011 geplant.
Wir hoffen, dass die Ärzte eine objektive Schlussfolgerung zur geistigen Gesundheit von Anna Shavenkova ziehen und das Gericht eine faire Entscheidung sowohl in Bezug auf die Wahl einer strafrechtlichen Bestrafung gegen sie als auch in Bezug auf die Entschädigung für materielle und moralische Schäden, die von den Opfern verursacht wurden, treffen wird.