Russian judicial system may face personnel problems

[Частный детектив Нижний Новгород]

In the near future, the Russian judicial system may face certain personnel problems. In the structure, which almost never lacked personnel, there was an outflow of both experienced judges and youth. The number of representatives of the Russian judicial community who decided to say goodbye to the once-desired mantle began to increase markedly.

At the same time, judicial chairs leave or plan to do so, both experienced servants of Themis and young lawyers. This problem may become especially sensitive for Moscow and other Russian megacities, Kommersant writes. According to the chairman of the capital qualification collegium of judges, Alexei Marinenko, this year about a quarter more judges may resign this year than in the past.

“Everyone is in a hurry to get a resignation, or they are afraid that they will cancel the severance pay,” Alexander Chernov, a member of the Higher Qualification Collegium of Judges of the Russian Federation, the chairman of the Krasnodar Regional Court, when the VKKS had to accept the resignation of several dozen judges at once. And on May 24, at a plenary meeting of the Council of Judges of the Russian Federation, it became clear that these fears are not unfounded. Its members were presented with the text of the bill "On Amending the Law of the Russian Federation" On the Status of Judges in the Russian Federation "and the Federal Law" On Additional Guarantees of Social Protection of Judges and Employees of the Apparatus of the Courts of the Russian Federation "in terms of determining the length of service as a judge." It provides that the right to monthly life support and severance pay will be reserved only for those retiring judges who have served 15 years in court and have reached the age of 55 for women and 60 for men. At the same time, the project relates only to the judicial experience of work the time of work as a judge.

In support of the project, it was argued that the new regulation would increase the prestige of the judicial profession and exclude cases of influx of people who were greedy for benefits, random people, to judicial posts. However, speakers at a meeting of the Council of Judges did not agree with this, no one approved this idea on the sidelines. The head of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation, Anton Ivanov, said that the judicial system needs to be replenished with different lawyers: both lawyers and corporate lawyers, and made it clear that the proposed reform will prevent this. Judge of the Supreme Arbitration Court Anatoly Pershutov recalled that the judicial system has already lost many people who have resigned, fearing the introduction of new regulation and the loss of benefits. If the project was adopted, Pershutov predicted, people 40–45 years old would come to work in the courts, and there would be no young cadres.

Then, in early June, the Council of Judges proposed a compromise on the issue of judicial experience for a secured resignation. The judicial community body decided to approve the draft “On Amending the Federal Law“ On Additional Guarantees of Social Protection of Judges and Employees of the Apparatus of the Courts of the Russian Federation ”in terms of determining the length of service as a judge” and, as the text of the decision says, “send it to the Ministry Finance of the Russian Federation for the further implementation of the decision of the Constitutional Court. " However, as amended by the Council of Judges, this draft law allows for the previous work of a prosecutor, investigator and lawyer as part of the judicial service of a retiring judge, provided that the length of service directly in the office of a judge is at least 10 years.

Regarding the provisions of the bill on increasing the age of judges' resignation (it is proposed to increase it from 50 to 55 years for women and from 55 to 60 years for men), the Council of Judges, apparently, has so far preferred not to speak out. At least, no documents have been published on this subject.

It is possible that all these factors led to the fact that, as it turned out at a meeting of the Council of Judges of Moscow, 77 judges resigned over the past nine months, while 79 applications for resignation were granted in all of 2010.

In addition, the planned changes and additions to Art. 217 of the Tax Code, according to which the severance pay of judges will be taxed at 13 percent (the corresponding bill has already been passed by the State Duma in the first reading). For the servants of Themis, who have worked as judges for 20 years, this allowance is approximately 2 million rubles. Considering that the monthly life-long maintenance of a judge (pension) with the same length of service is 54 thousand rubles, many people think about going to a well-deserved rest without loss in the form of income tax, Kommersant thinks.

However, the chairman of the CCM of Moscow Marinenko believes that not all judges with length of service will quit so as not to lose in payments. "The loss of 13% [of income tax] - 250-300 thousand rubles - not the amount to lose a prestigious and well-paid job."

Pravo.ru (pravo.ru), 10/25/2011

 

[DIBNN]

A holy place is never empty.
: ugeek:

 

[Евгений СБ]

Thank.

 

[Саратов-Алиби]

There are no irreplaceable ones!

 

[НСК-СБ]

Horoooooooshie their pensions ..... Thank you, Vladimir!

 

[Евгений СБ]

Horoooooooshie their pensions ..... Thank you, Vladimir!

Their salaries are not bad either.

 

[Игорь]

They leave, that's for sure, a friend worked for a long time in court and now he left in order not to lose the allowance of 50 years and a lifetime allowance of 49 thousand rubles. He smokes bamboo and gives paid advice.