Call recording

[Anonymous]

Good evening, dear colleagues.
My friend recommended that I contact you. I want to consult with you.
Tell me if there is such an opportunity.

Essence of the question:
Citizen A recorded Citizen B on a Ritmix brand voice recorder. This record was submitted to the civil court, where the judge accepted the record transferred to the CD-ROM as evidence.
Question: did citizen A lawfully act with respect to citizen B, if not, what law is it prohibited?

 

[Детективное агентство Симферополь]

Honestly, it’s hard to immediately recall which law is regulated by law, but before recording c. And should have notified gr. B about the ongoing recording of negotiations, that is, in this case, the recording does not have legal force, since there was no notification, and it would be interesting to know on the basis of what law the judge accepted the recording. Maybe all the same there was a notice, and c. Would you go to failure?

 

[Детективное агентство Тула]

Citizen A recorded Citizen B on a Ritmix brand voice recorder.

Everyone puts their meaning into the verb "wrote down."
What is the point you put into it? I’m specifically interested in the circumstances of the production of the recording of gr. AND groups B ?
For example:
1. AND recorded a conversation B with her husband. The conversation took place between the spouses in the kitchen of their apartment, where AND managed to put the recorder on the eve, unnoticed by the owners, secretly penetrating through the window through the fire escape.
2. AND recorded a telephone conversation B with her lovers - FROM by connecting to a neighbor’s telephone wire, secretly from her.
3. AND recorded my conversation with B when she scolded him for being AND secretly peed at their common porch.

 

[Детективное агентство Тула]

the judge accepted the record transferred to the CD as evidence.

Although, if the judge is a qualified lawyer and has already accepted the record as evidence, then your clarifications are superfluous ....

 

[Anonymous]

Record made unfamiliar person.

 

[Детективное агентство Тула]

Record made unfamiliar person.

I am interested in the circumstances of the production of the record: who, whom, where, when, how, etc.
LEARN MORE! Any little thing can affect the qualification of the act of recording ...

 

[Детективное агентство Тула]

As far as I remember the civil process, then there, obtaining evidence is entrusted to him.
He brought A record B to court as evidence - well done!
But if, during the recording, the constitutional rights protected by the Law B were violated, then the evidence during the process can be considered NULL, since they were obtained in violation of the Law ...
In the place of attorney B, I would "dig" in this direction.

 

[Частный детектив]

CIVIL PROCEDURAL CODE OF UKRAINE
Chapter 5
EVIDENCE

Article 57. Evidence
1. Evidence is any factual data on the basis of which the court
establishes the presence or absence of substantiating circumstances
requirements and objections of the parties, and other relevant circumstances
to resolve the case.
2. These data are established on the basis of explanations of the parties, the third parties
persons, their representatives, interrogated as witnesses, testimony of witnesses,
written evidence, physical evidence, including audio and video recordings ,,
expert opinions.

Article 58. Belonging of evidence
1. Evidence containing information on the subject is appropriate
proving.
2. The parties have the right to justify the affiliation of a particular
evidence to substantiate their claims or objections.
3. The court shall not consider evidence that is not relevant to the subject
proving.

Article 59. Admissibility of evidence
1. The court shall not take into account evidence obtained in violation
the order established by the law.
2. The circumstances of the case, which by law must be confirmed
by certain means of proof, cannot be confirmed by others
means of proof.

Russian version
CIVIL PROCEDURAL CODE OF UKRAINE
Chapter 5
EVIDENCE

Article 57. evidence
1. Evidence is any factual data on the basis of which the court
establishes the presence or absence of substantiating circumstances
requirements and objections of the parties, and other relevant circumstances
to resolve the case.
2. These data are established on the basis of explanations of the parties, the third parties
persons, their representatives, interrogated as witnesses, testimony of witnesses,
written evidence, physical evidence, in particular audio and video recordings ,,
expert opinions.

Article 58. Belonging of evidence
1. Evidence containing information about the subject is appropriate
evidence.
2. The parties have the right to justify the affiliation of a particular
evidence to substantiate their claims or objections.
3. The court shall not accept for consideration evidence that does not relate to the subject
evidence.

Article 59. Admissibility of evidence
1. The court does not take into account the evidence obtained in violation
the order established by the law.
2. The circumstances of the case, which by law must be confirmed
certain means of proof cannot be confirmed by others
means of proof.

 

[Anonymous]

A deal was made to purchase a quarter. It was discussed about the issue of funds deposited in a bank cell.
Gr. A third party recorded a conversation between a buyer and a seller.
And then, on behalf of the seller of the apartment, I submitted a record to the court.

 

[Anonymous]

It was in Russia.