Private detectives may threaten the rights of Kazakhstanis

[Частный детектив. Timofey. Челябинск.]

The introduction of the law on private detectives may violate the constitutional rights of Kazakhstanis. This was stated by Minister of Justice Berik Imashev, a Tengrinews.kz correspondent reports.

"This is a very complex concept. What is the law on private investigative activity? This is the law on private operational activity, that is, we must allow private individuals, at the discretion of private individuals, to intervene in the lives of other private individuals. Here, as if not to break the law and the rights of citizens. Law enforcement agencies have a lot of questions in this part. The expert community, lawyers are asking questions: is there a constitutional basis for this legislation? We have been instructed, we are trying. Accordingly, we get a portion of criticism in this part, "said Berik Imashev reporters after an hour in the Majilis.

The Minister emphasized that, first of all, the law enforcement agencies are the opponents of the bill.

“There is an opinion that the oligarchs are for this law, because they have money to pay for private detective detectives. (...) How many times have we passed (the bill - Approx. Author), law enforcement agencies are against, because they believe that in this the case violates the constitutional rights of citizens, "said the head of the Ministry of Justice.

Berik Imashev noted that the adoption of the law on private detectives is not a single day issue, and whether the ministry will manage to coordinate all the nuances with all interested parties by the end of the year is a big question.

"There are deadlines. This year it should be worked out. But it is clear that no consensus will be reached ... We have a deadline for extension. You know, once it was introduced 3-4 years ago, it was withdrawn by the government. There, indeed, the question was raised of what would go to the Constitutional Council, "the minister explained, answering journalists' questions.

More details: [DLMURL="https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/chastnyie-detektivyi-mogut-ugrojat-konstitutsionnyim-pravam-kazahstantsev--221155/"] https://tengrinews.kz/kazakhstan_news/ch ... v --221155 / [/ DLMURL]
Any use of materials is allowed only with a hyperlink to Tengrinews.kz

 

[Андрей Захаров]

Yeah ... Apparently, our colleagues from Kazakhstan are having a hard time ... All over the world, our brethren do not violate the rights of citizens, but in Kazakhstan they will certainly violate ... Something the legislators of Kazakhstan are wondering about ...

 

[Детектив-Молдова]

The introduction of the law on private detectives may violate the constitutional rights of Kazakhstanis ...

In my opinion, not to pass such a law would violate and limit the constitutional rights of citizens even more!
I don’t know how things are with democratic principles, with democracy in Kazakhstan, but DEMOCRACY in any state, it is assessed by how many of its competencies delegated this state to society, the private sector.
In this case, the face of the same confrontation between the public sector and the private sector, which takes place, even in the same Ukraine. But all this for the time being, for the time being. Some time will pass and they will realize in Kazakhstan that the time has passed when the state should hold a monopoly over everything and everyone.

 

[Плотников Юрий Михайлович]

Yeah ... Apparently, our colleagues from Kazakhstan are having a hard time ... All over the world, our brethren do not violate the rights of citizens, but in Kazakhstan they will certainly violate ... Something the legislators of Kazakhstan are wondering about ...

So I think so, oh weird!

 

[Zhomart]

It’s very difficult for our colleagues to live in a medieval state. By the way, this Mr. Imashev Berik is my classmate, but this does not affect the promotion of the law, I think he is one of the opponents of the law. I will not tell you a big secret - he belongs to the family, of course

 

[Детектив-Молдова]

... he belongs to the family, it is clear which

So, here comes the question of who violates the constitutional rights of citizens more and who hinders the development of the state and society as a whole? :!:
One can only predict what kind of revolution Kazakhstan is expecting ...

 

[Роберт]

It seems to me that in justice they have some oligos who are not close in their minds ...: D Then think for yourself: D

 

[Роберт]

If with a normal thought process, then we could pass a normal law with all rights and give a license only to citizens of a country with a higher education: D and a license cost of 50,000 bucks to set. And there will never be detectives in Kazakhstan, because this is the budget of a small area .....: D: D: D

 

[Патрушев Михаил Владимирович]

I think so, since the detective has a license, he is guided by law and bears full responsibility for this!
Sovereign people (from the Ministry of Internal Affairs) are simply afraid of a counterweight, envy, etc.
They are always afraid, either of excess, or of sticking, as always!
And among them, especially recently after the reform of the Ministry of Internal Affairs in Russia, you can only hear in the media about the criminal behavior of individual employees. Just as they took bribes, they still take. Like they killed, they kill. Like they committed an accident, they began to commit even more. This does not apply to everyone, but for some reason it often happens.
A monologue from the film “The White Sun of the Desert,” the actor spoke out: “... not for himself, but for the power it’s insulting ...” So, who should trust who and whom ... or not ?!

 

[Роберт]

Oh, it’s “White Sun .....” to me: D And you know that in St. Petersburg there is a monument to the customs officer played by P. Luspekaev ....: D: D: DEvery year is October 25 (the day of my birth and all customs) flowers solemnly lay. : D That is, it is believed that there are no real heroes in this service !!!! Like that! : D: D: D
And about our license and how detectives are hunted so that novels can be made to excite 203 or 159.
By the way, you need to create a separate topic on the forum about how and who develops our brother and what comes of it. So, a small course OBZH: D