Case. Inspection as a way of analyzing texts.

[Ющук Евгений Леонидович]

[DLMURL="https://yushchuk.livejournal.com/363575.html"] Source - Competitive Intelligence Blog [/ DLMURL]

The ability to analyze texts is important for a specialist Competitive intelligence skill. In the course of Igor Nezhdanov, "Text Analysis", in particular, such a simple and at the same time effective analytical technique, as "Inspection" is described. Inspection allows not only to significantly reduce the amount of information that requires understanding, and thereby save time, but also to cut off emotions, and just opinions, from facts.
I will show you how it looks - on the example of the text of an Orthodox priest who visited Tolokonnikova from Pussy Rayot in the colony Nadezhda (Tolokno).

The priest text I discovered Facebook Alexei Vdovin:

This is a fragment of the original material that caused the greatest polemic on Facebook by Alexei Vdovin:

Priest's visit to IK-14: Tolokonnikova is tired of the game in which she was dragged
September 26, 2013 • Archpriest Alexander Pelin

... Well, and most importantly, I managed, although not for long, to talk with Nadezhda Tolokonnikova. Currently, she is in a separate room in the colony. The building is guarded in a special way. Since she expressed concerns in her statement for her life, she is currently being held in a separate room for two people. She is there alone and is under surveillance. Nearby there is a doctor who can come up at any moment, monitor her well-being, since she has also gone on a hunger strike.

Near the colony is constantly Peter Verzilov, the husband of Tolokonnikova, whom we also met when we arrived. We unloaded gingerbread cookies, cookies, tea brought with us for distribution to convicts. Verzilov was nearby, maybe he thought that some regular human rights activists had arrived. There were no provocations on his part, they just said hello, that's where it all ended.

At first, Nadezhda had a long talk today with the president of the Interregional Charitable Assistance Fund for Prisoners Maria Cannabih and the famous journalist Elena Masiuk. Then I went to her.

A small cell, with a bathroom behind the partition, similar to a hospital ward. Hope sat on a made-up bed, wrote something. I asked: “Do you want to talk to me?” She says: “Yes, please come in.” I asked literally a few minutes from my colleagues, because someone also wanted to continue the conversation. I went in, sat opposite, I asked: “Please tell me, Nadezhda, do you have any complaints about the ability of people in the colony to freely exercise their faith? Do they get hindered in this? ” She said that there were no obstacles, that people were free to go to the temple. Moreover, she admitted that she herself attended church. Her main complaint was that people do not have enough free time. That the authorities do not give them free time, as a result, they can pay little attention to themselves. I asked her a few more questions regarding her spiritual condition.

Speaking with Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, I saw before me a far from exhausted and abnormal person. She is perfectly sane, very clearly aware of her actions and looks like a completely healthy person - both mentally and physically.

When I asked if she wanted to receive a blessing and accept the paper Kazan icon of the Mother of God (we handed out such images to many prisoners), she gladly accepted it.

I think she is not lost to society. And I got the impression that she was already tired of the game that her husband was pulling her into, or maybe some of the forces that she owed - position, money, or earned that way, sorry for the expression, in a mean way, fame . And she is aware of this, in part, at least. This is not a revolutionary with crazy eyes, she does not burn with malice, hatred or revenge, like individual convicts whom I also met.

For example, there is a closed room, which contains malicious violators of the regime. We also went there, along with the mufti. Four people talked, he talked with a Muslim from Astrakhan, and I - with a nominal Christian. And that was expressed quite harshly and even aggressively in relation to the Church. Like, she doesn’t need intermediaries, and she doesn’t like everything ...

Hope showed nothing of the kind. She did not say blasphemy or filth, was not rude, but, on the contrary, was very friendly, polite and neat.

At the end of the conversation, I expressed the hope that maybe she will be able to more correctly set her life priorities. I think, perhaps, she would like to stop this barren fuss and her such presentation. Maybe she does not yet fully realize what she is doing. I wished her to quickly get rid of the illusions that there are some people who will decide everything for her, be it her husband or some other forces behind her. For there is a feeling that she is an instrument in someone’s game, which aims to discredit and discredit everything that is important to us.

Yes, there are still many problems in the penal system. Yes, it’s hard for everyone there. But, believe me, every year the situation improves, the attitude towards prisoners is becoming more humane. Today, public oversight commissions and human rights defenders have a huge impact. They can visit virtually any correctional institution, watch, control everything - food, maintenance, attitude to prisoners, sanitary conditions. There are many forms of public control now, which is good. And the more difficult it becomes to discredit the penal system.

If you discredit the army, the Church, law enforcement agencies and other institutions that, in essence, protect us, then there will be nothing left that would ensure the normal functioning of the Russian state. The consequences can be tragic, up to the destruction of Russia. Maybe this is exactly what people who are behind the claims of Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, the actions of her husband and some other characters called human rights activists want?


Commenting on the material, people were divided into those who are “For the Pusek” and “Against the Pusek”. The arguments of the parties are not the subject of this post, so I did not copy them here. Who cares about this part - the discussion is available on Facebook,

And here is a synopsis of the same fragment:

A conversation with Tolokonnikova took place. She took place in a guarded building in the presence of a medic.
Before contact with Tolokonnikova, there was a meeting with Verzilov, she went quietly, without provocation.
Hope receives delegations in a live queue. I have to wait.
Tolokonnikova agreed to the conversation.
In response to a question, she said that it is possible to pray in the colony without hindrance. Tolokonnikova also said that she goes to church.
Tolokonnikova gives the impression of a physically and mentally healthy person.
She accepted the Kazan icon of the Mother of God, at the same time she was delighted.
The author believes that “she is not lost to society”, “she’s tired of the game in which she is drawn into”, “this is not a revolutionary”, “she does not burn with malice, hatred or revenge”. The lack of aggressiveness distinguishes her from a number of other prisoners.
Tolokonnikova did not say blasphemy or filth, was not rude, but, on the contrary, was very friendly, polite and neat.
At the end of the conversation, the author called on the prisoner to rethink his behavior and take responsibility for his own fate. Tolokonnikova’s reaction to this is unknown.
In jail is bad. There are those who seek to discredit the punishment system. But there are human rights activists - they make the situation public.
The author believes that the discrediting of the penitentiary system may be part of discrediting state institutions in order to weaken the state. He admits that a number of resonant persons are used “blindly” for these purposes.

 

[Бедеров Игорь Сергеевич]

Inspection should concern and directly concerns factology. There is a fact there is a record. Thus, we obtain facts, not the emotional burden of the author and his perception, with the exception of those moments when the perception of the author itself misleads him (manipulating perception based on expected or obvious norms).

In the case, like the case of a fork in a circle, the author’s misconceptions in fact, all further notes and interpretations will be distorted.

 

[Матушкин Андрей Николаевич]

Thank.
Very curious.

 

[Турабян Владимир]

THANK!

 

[Ющук Евгений Леонидович]

Inspection should concern and directly concerns factology. There is a fact there is a record. Thus, we obtain facts, not the emotional burden of the author and his perception, with the exception of those moments when the perception of the author itself misleads him (manipulating perception based on expected or obvious norms).

In the case, like the case of a fork in a circle, the author’s misconceptions in fact, all further notes and interpretations will be distorted.

I do not quite agree. When taking notes, the facts from the speculation are taken into account and indicated.

But, of course, if initially something sounds in the text as a fact, it will fall into the synopsis the same way. Because it is a compendium of a specific text, its task is to make the text suitable for understanding, to reveal contradictions, to highlight the texture. And this is done not just like that, but for some reason. Intelligence is not engaged in "pure art", it ALWAYS has a specific task. Here, from the angle of solving this problem, and not "in general," the text is analyzed.

 

[Бедеров Игорь Сергеевич]

Got it now. Immediately you need to analyze from the right angle ... Thank you.

Just by reading I had no direction and did not adjust my angle of view. I personally did not care about Pussy.

 

[Ющук Евгений Леонидович]

Immediately you need to analyze from the right angle ...

Yes. There is an opinion that the analysis begins at the stage of selecting a document. After all, somehow you need to select from the entire information array those documents that will then be analyzed. Accordingly, this can only be done with some specific task. You can, of course, simply row and fold “for later” everything that contains some words - if the resources allow it to be done. But this is not analytics, this is an information vacuum cleaner.

 

[Бедеров Игорь Сергеевич]

Evgeny Leonidovich, tell me software for collecting an array of textual information. For example, I have lists of business center employees over many years, how to correctly select an array of data, given their transitions by position, dismissal, return, change of telephones, cars, etc.

 

[Ющук Евгений Леонидович]

Evgeny Leonidovich, tell me software for collecting an array of textual information. For example, I have lists of business center employees over many years, how to correctly select an array of data, given their transitions by position, dismissal, return, change of telephones, cars, etc.

It seems to me that you better ask this at the Forum https://forum.razved.info/ ) I do not specialize in this and I can’t competently tell, and there are those who are deeply in this topic at the Forum.

 

[Бедеров Игорь Сергеевич]

I’ll definitely try, I would also like to invite them to participate in the forum.