New in the Criminal Code

[Арсен]

I OFFER MY BILL:
1. Allow Private Detectives to use Special Techniques, provided that these actions are actively
contribute to the suppression and investigation of crime. (a private detective will be required to prove this fact).
2. Allow Private Detectives to carry and, if necessary, use at least traumatic weapons and special equipment.
3. Allow Private Detectives to detain persons suspected of committing a crime (these actions must be performed when
sufficient grounds).
4. Allow Private Detectives to freely and, if necessary, use the databases of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.
5. To oblige the Territorial Internal Affairs Bodies to transmit to the mail server the Private Detectives registered in this
territorial division of LRR targeting the perpetrators of the crime.
6. Allow Private Detectives to investigate cases, conduct investigative actions.

That's all for now! And then maybe it will be easier.

 

[Андрей Захаров]

Arsen))) In order to give the BH such “powers”, all, without exception, the BH should have at least a higher legal education, practical experience in the bodies of preliminary investigation or inquiry (regarding the investigation of cases), etc. .. Then The question is, how will the BH differ from the employee of the state structure and is the BH institute necessary then ... Carefully look at the BHH Act and other normative acts in general ... BH is not a person endowed with the functions of law enforcement ... We - ordinary merchants who provide data collection services to specific individuals, in the interests of these individuals ... And that’s all ... We have nothing to do with law enforcement agencies and should not ... These are functions of a pure state ... that the BH supposedly "investigates" some kind of criminal case, catching criminals is a myth ... We just can assist an interested citizen in collecting information on criminal cases ... Wow ... However, this is not an investigation (take a word, I have rich experience) ... All this is the influence of the media that make BH some kind of halo ... For some reason, even representatives of the Kyrgyz Republic, who, in my opinion, should have figured this out, also believe that BH is a person, which investigates crimes, carries out some kind of protection, etc. .. All this is far from the case and it is necessary, probably, to get rid of this opinion, because it is not true .... Believe the practice ...

 

[Арсен]

Arsen))) In order to give the BH such “powers”, all, without exception, the BH should have at least a higher legal education, practical experience in the bodies of preliminary investigation or inquiry (regarding the investigation of cases), etc. .. Then The question is, how will the BH differ from the employee of the state structure and is the BH institute necessary then ... Carefully look at the BHH Act and other normative acts in general ... BH is not a person endowed with the functions of law enforcement ... We - ordinary merchants who provide data collection services to specific individuals, in the interests of these individuals ... And that’s all ... We have nothing to do with law enforcement agencies and should not ... These are functions of a pure state ... that the BH supposedly "investigates" some kind of criminal case, catching criminals is a myth ... We just can assist an interested citizen in collecting information on criminal cases ... Wow ... However, this is not an investigation (take a word, I have rich experience) ... All this is the influence of the media that make BH some kind of halo ... For some reason, even representatives of the Kyrgyz Republic, who, in my opinion, should have figured this out, also believe that BH is a person, which investigates crimes, carries out some kind of protection, etc. .. All this is far from the case and it is necessary, probably, to get rid of this opinion, because it is not true .... Believe the practice ...

Andrey Valerievich! So I wish BH to be not an ordinary comedian, but a person who will be endowed with certain powers. And so for us so far I do not see a particular prospect. Our services, as if we were not trying, are very expensive.
An ordinary person who has trouble cannot get normal help without money. In the West, BH has much more opportunities
than we have in Russia. In general, I think that it is necessary to combine Security and Detective Activities, i.e. issue a single
license for example: PRIVATE SECURE ACTIVITY. After all, all the same, even most security structures are engaged
and private detectives or vice versa, private detectives are engaged in the safety of citizens, etc.

 

[Андрей Захаров]

Aresen))) So it used to be (at the time of adoption of the Law) ... It was possible to create security detective units (see the Law in the first edition) ... Then all this was canceled (banning mixed activities) .... I think -what is right, because structures appeared that formally duplicate state ones. However, this matter does not fundamentally change ... It all depends on what kind of people are engaged in this type of activity ... After all, a person who has a desire to help people in the field of law enforcement has the opportunity to go to law enforcement bodies to work and, being in the "sovereign" service, provide services free of charge and in good faith (at the expense of the state, of course, and not at the expense of an individual customer) to protect their rights ... This is the way out of this situation ... (for those who want to try their hand at such a job). Moreover, the salary there is now normal (with respect to the course, of the order of 40-50 tr). And NPV is a purely commercial activity, designed not to duplicate the functions of law enforcement agencies, but simply to provide various types of services to citizens and legal entities in those areas of activity where law enforcement agencies cannot provide them to a specific citizen or legal entity due to the specifics of their activities. ... And, of course, it would be ideal if such types of services were provided by professionals who have experience working in the system of law enforcement agencies and special services. That a citizen or legal entity would receive a quality service performed by a person who is not by hearsay, but by the practice gained during the "sovereign" service received any practical skills in collecting information of interest ...