Working meeting with a member of the Public Chamber of the Russian Federation

[Детективное агентство Тула]

Alexandra, of course, well done. And what will it give us?

If I understand something in strategy and tactics, in this way our Partnership (IAPD) is trying to take a worthy part in the preparation of the draft law “On Amending the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation (in terms of providing the participants in criminal proceedings with the right to use the services of a private detective to collect information on the criminal case and use the information received from it to protect the rights and legitimate interests. "

It is a pity that the topic proposed by Alexandra Igorevna in early December 2015

Link

was not professionally worked out at the Forum.

 

[Детектив-Молдова]

Glad for the successes achieved!

 

[ВАХТАНГ-ГРУЗИЯ]

I support!

 

[Виктор Сергеевич]

We are going in the right direction.

 

[Александра]

Konstantin Mikhailovich, absolutely true. I look forward to constructive proposals and unrequitedly.

 

[Детективное агентство Тула]

Alexandra Igorevna, more optimism!

 

[Андрей Захаров]

Alexandra Igorevna))) And now let's try to organize statistical studies regarding the work of the BH in criminal cases .... Look at how many and who generally takes part in collecting information on criminal cases .... do these BHs have any problems in the exercise of their rights given by the BH Law when collecting this information .... And only then, if there are any problems in terms of exercising the rights of private detectives, it will be possible to talk about whether these changes are necessary in the CPC (in terms of work BH), and in other Laws .... But for this you need to at least find out exactly how many BHs participated in the collection of information on criminal cases, the categories of these children .... After that, you need to prepare a questionnaire on possible problems and then, analyze the results .... Now, if all this is implemented and the real picture is seen, then it will only be possible to decide if it is worth making any changes to the Laws .... However, all these measures for statistical research are very hemorrhoids , require a lot of time .... and it is unlikely that anyone will do all this for free ... especially since, theoretically, those people who are preparing legislative initiatives and get a certain reward for this should do it all. ... So volunteers in this matter are unlikely to be found .... After all, no one even knows at present the exact number of simply working black holes ... Not declaring their work, namely working .... The problem will even be just to make a list of these BHs .... Something like this .... here they are .... specific proposals .... By the way ... the total number of registered BHs can be found on the Ministry of Internal Affairs website (moreover, by name) , but not everyone will be there ... Although it’s possible that there will be about 1000 people registered in the Russian Federation ... of which “workers” may be around 350-400 ... maybe less .... then you will need to contact each registered as a black hole by a person and to conduct his survey on the questionnaire .... And it may well turn out that A rum of information on criminal cases from this list is handled by a maximum of a dozen, maybe fewer people .... who may have never had any problems regarding the legalization of the information that they obtained .... And in this case, no amendments to the Law, in particular the same Code of Criminal Procedure, will ever pass ... no matter how "good" they are .... due to the lack of the need to introduce them ....

 

[JR Security Consulting Group]

Reasonable Andrew!