Lyubimenko Sergey Alexandrovich, President of the APS.

[Матушкин Андрей Николаевич]

Friends, good day!
Today Sergey Aleksandrovich Lyubimenko called me with an interesting proposal for a joint event. Much of it is not clear, at least in terms of time (announced a week before the event), there was no possibility before, or the idea came at the last moment. Sergey Alexandrovich suggested that our Association act as a co-organizer of this event. With the venue, according to him, there is still no clarity, maybe it will be in the Public Chamber of St. Petersburg, or maybe not. He is interested in whether we can offer a venue (all from his words).
I ask everyone who is "in the subject" to speak on this issue. Event information below.

The event is announced in the plan of the Public Chamber

Russian Federation for 2019. ​

Round table on the topic:

“Non-state security system as an important element of an integrated system of state security”

The first event in the 2019 round of hearings (round tables) in seven federal districts of Russia. Held in conjunction with the Coordinating Council of the Non-State Security Sphere (NSS)

Date: 02/19. 2019 year

Time: 11.00-14.00.

Location: St. Petersburg. Civic Chamber of St. Petersburg of the Russian Federation,

Organizer: Commission of the Public Chamber of the Russian Federation for Security and Cooperation with PMCs (M.S.

Presenter: M.S. Anichkin, Deputy Chairman of the Commission on Security and Cooperation with the PMC.

Number of participants: 50 people

Speakers (participants): representatives of regional structures of the non-state security sector and enterprises engaged in the provision of private security services in the North-Western District, representatives of state authorities, regional law enforcement agencies, representatives of veteran associations.

The purpose of the event:

Preparation of materials for the further development of the Concept of Non-State Security System.

Final document:

Interim Resolution on the Problems of the Development of the Private Security System in the Okrug

 

[Детектив-Юг]

Dear colleagues, licensed private detectives!

The first question arises, who is Sergey Alexandrovich Lyubimenko and what organization or community does he represent?

 

[Матушкин Андрей Николаевич]

Dear colleagues, licensed private detectives!

The first question arises, who is Sergey Alexandrovich Lyubimenko and what organization or community does he represent?

He represents the Association of Investigation Professionals, he is its President.
He was a member of our Association, was even a Vice-President, but he was expelled for not paying membership dues.

 

[Детектив-Юг]

Googled the Internet and found nothing but PR, and most importantly, in the vicinity of the Association of Detective Professionals, I did not notice anyone and anything related to real detective work.
The organization’s website contains the Register of issued licenses for private detective (detective) activities for 2013 and 2015, if Mr. Lyubimenko considers them his army, then he is deeply mistaken.
Also, he should know that the real number of detectives is to fold one order from the total amount given on the site.

Interesting, Lyubimenko Sergey Alexandrovich is a private detective or did he pass by?
It is also interesting how many private detectives are in his association, not members but BHs having licenses and, accordingly, voting rights?

 

[Частный детектив. Панда. Краснодар.]

Good day, colleagues. Allow me to express my opinion on the conduct of this event and specifically on the personality of Lyubimenko S.A. In February 2014, we, members of the International Association of Detectives: Matushkina A.N., Demidenko O., Turabyan V., Gudimova A., Gorovikova M., were invited to this event, which was held in Moscow in the Congress Hall, organized by the Public Chamber of the Russian Federation . Mr. Lyubimenko was promised to us, everyone’s presentation and round tables with a presentation of our organization, i.e. International Association of Detectives. We all prepared reports, some came from other cities of Russia, but we did not wait for the promised. When asked Lyubimenko S.A. why this happened, he only shrugged and said that he was not guilty of anything, although he positioned himself before this as one of the main leaders in preparing the event. Therefore, I do not know whether to participate in this project.
As for Lyubimenko SA, he tells all the sites that he is the vice president of the MOD, a member of our organization. But as far as I remember, he was expelled from the current members of the MOU, for the non-payment of membership fees in the summer of 2018, if I'm wrong, then let me correct Andrei Nikolaevich.

 

[Андрей Захаров]

In principle, I completely agree with Victor on the issue that the APS public association does not represent the real interests of working licensed BHs ... Everything that Lyubimenko himself says about allegedly active activity in the field of the private investigation of this public association is just water .... Even based on the information that it possibly represents the interests of security companies .... this is real .... and private detectives it is .... a formal appendage ... there is no real benefit from the activities of the PA APS to the professional community of licensed BHs in principle, no .... At least it is not visible at all)))) About his real activities just like BH did not hear anything .... although formally he in my opinion has a license ..... Based on what he said dear Mikhail, in principle, the conclusion is unequivocal ..... Without a clear program and a clear confirmed plan for the above activities, indicating specific performers, duly agreed upon, which Liu should present bimenko, it makes no sense in my opinion to "fit in" with this topic .... All this, in my opinion, is just another PR campaign in order to "promote" a little and show its significance .... although there is no significance in my opinion, because there is no real return on the activities of this formal association of the PA AO .... We don’t even know who is in this association (lists are not published at all .... although it is declared that there are some licensed BHs) ... Although I tried before to find out this question from representatives of this same APS .... but the question remained unanswered ....

 

[aleksandr]

It seems to me that it is necessary to participate in such events and convey to the authorities our wishes in the formation of legislation. Another thing, who invites?

 

[Детективное агентство ОПЦИОН]

My opinion is that since Lyubimenko turned here, it means that he does not have a stone flower. Once, as Mikhail said so, then why step on the same rake twice. I think that we have many authoritative St. Petersburg comrades who can easily reach members of the public chamber and if the event is really worthwhile, then be present there as an independent association and express the aspirations of our community.

 

[Детектив-Юг]

In Russia, the main problem of Private detective work is that everyone is talking about and discussing this problem while trying to draft law except for the private detectives themselves, who are exclusively Licensed Private Detectives, and not those passing by.

 

[Сергей Анатольевич]

Colleagues, good afternoon.
I’ll also insert my five cents ...
I, like many of those present, are at the origins of the creation of the association.
I try to participate in all events, I have been friends with Matushkin since 2008.
I perfectly remember the 4th conference of the MOD.
At that conference Lyubimenko arrived with his boss.
They were accepted as relatives, both of them were put on the podium ...
"Not good voices" to Andrei (Matushkin), they said a lot ...
And that the "guest performers" came to St. Petersburg to build their own Association on the bones of the MOD, and that they would "marry and quit" ...
Sergei Alexandrovich at this conference handed out his application for entry into the APS, join - for free ...
There were naive people who took everything at face value ... it's me about MOD, they entered.
Then he waved these profiles before the "serious uncles", he is called in some "not good people" detectives of all Russia)))
Andrei sacredly believed that people are decent, decent ... apparently human wisdom is true, that everyone judges by himself ...
How things went on ...
Above, you read what Mikhail Gorovikov wrote about the round table ...
Lyubimenko also participated in our 7th conference, again crawled into the podium ...
I know that Andrei Nikolaevich planned to hold the 8th conference in Moscow at the Public Chamber ...
Andrei traveled to Moscow, met with Galochkin ...
He came from Moscow, pleased ... he says they agreed with Dmitry Evgenich, he will help to spend in the Public Chamber.
Again, "not good voices" they say to him, these "Muscovites" will "deceive you" ...
No, they’re not like that ...)))))
Cheated!
The 8th Moscow Conference was held in Moscow, but not in the Public Chamber of the Russian Federation.
And what do you think?
Again on her Lyubimenko ... though this time they didn’t let him on the podium!
Those who know how to read, I was able to draw conclusions about these "comrades", which we are not at all comrades ...